Tuesday, 25 March 2008

  • Currently Reading
    Do Hard Things: A Teenage Rebellion Against Low Expectations
    By Alex Harris, Brett Harris
    see related

    Kid Myths and War Lies

    Do Hard Things: Ignore Social Myths and Get to Know a Real Kid

    I was provided with a copy of this book a couple weeks ago by a friend who thought I might find it interesting from a religious perspective and the perspective of the parent of a teen. The book is getting a lot of advance buzz in churches, youth groups, etc. and it's precocious authors have become heroes to the "society is going to hell because of kids these days" types who have certainly already made this an Amazon pre-order bestseller and will set the blogosphere afire with impassioned pleas for all teens to read it and be saved from their apathy and sloth.

    I don't question the authors' heart, faith or intentions. I think it could be an inspirational read for anyone (regardless of age) who may feel he or she isn't trying to live up to his or her fullest potential or that life has been lived in an underwhelming manner due to low expectations. The problem I have is the assumption by the authors and the vocal proponents that the vast majority of kids are lazy, entitled and uncaring. I don't believe that the vast majority of teens need a call to service or, for that matter, service in God's name. The many myths about Generation Y that abound today are not backed up by the facts. Actual polling data shows teens and young adults more politically involved (look at their voting numbers in this year's primaries!), more socially aware, less aimlessly materialistic (a teens material desires today are more likely to gravitate to a productivity tool such as an iPhone or some other gadget than expensive jeans) and more serious about school (they graduate and attend college at the highest rates ever) than young people in generations. Yes they are self-centered; most teens (most people, in fact) are and always have been. Today's teens simply have more technology with which to show themselves off to the world. The YouTube Generation is more the product of an unprecedented ease with technology than a heightened sense of "look at me". They are, finally, more religious than any generation since World War II. Simply put, most of today's teens do not need this book to tell them what they already know. But many adults, unfortunately, want to use it as an imprimatur of their mistaken beliefs and a sign that someone is trying to help kids save themselves from themselves.

    If you Still Think that the Bush Administration Didn't Lie About Iraq

    The PBS series Frontline has a history of producing great, but little known, exposes. This weeks Bush's War is no exception. If you refuse to recognize the tonnage of evidence that shows the Bush Administration built the case to invade Iraq on a foundation of deceit then you should consider checking out this two-part series with an open mind (if you are capable of having one). Based on interviews with those who were there, the series features evidence of a litany of moves that show the Administration had Iraq in mind during the very hours following 9/11 and sought only to make a connection between that day and Iraq whether the intelligence backed it up or not.

    We hear of former Asst. Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz making the case that an Iraq connection must be made during the first White House meeting on 9/11, despite the CIA's quick identification of Osama Bin Laden and Al Queda as the responsible party.

    We see multiple confirmations of the fact that hijacker Mohammed Atta never met with an Iraqi agent in Prague (the FBI had him confirmed in Miami at the time) yet Dick Cheney continues to relay this as fact even two years after confirmation otherwise.

    Not to mention the voluminous stories of how the Administration botched the war's execution from the start -- flatly ignoring Army Chief of Staff, Gen. Eric Shinseki's troop need estimates and being, of course, proven tragically wrong by the current "surge" and now 4000+ dead. How they have mocked International treaties such as the Geneva Convention over the protest of lifelong warriors such as Colin Powell. Or how they have, as we know, demanded the Government be given unprecedented power to spy on US Citizens within our borders.

    If you have not already chugged the Bush Kool-Aid, you will find yourself growing angrier with every minute of Bush's War. At the same time, you may feel a growing sense of relief that the clock is winding down on one of the most destructive Presidencies in U.S. history.

Comments (3)

  • kenedwards5

    Interesting what you say about the kids in America. Do you base your opinions on Meg and her friends? Does she go to state or private school? The state schools here are mainly useless despite some well intentioned teachers. The rotten system beats them every time.

    Ken

  • robakamegansdad

    @kenedwards5 - Yes, Ken, I am influenced to some extent, of course, by Megan and her friends however I don't think that they are necessarily any different from most other kids their age. Of course there are kids who are problems but that is the small minority; unfortunately, the media and many adults tend to think that these bad apples actually represent the majority. Megan goes to a private school and that may be a factor but my belief is that good, motivated, kids rise above systematics problems in education. But the fact that she comes from a family of reasonble means probably plays a bigger role. I would guess 80+ percent of US schools operate well enough and most teachers are committed professionals. The system simply is not equipped nor is there any will to really fix the poorly performing 20% and that creates a massive gap between kids in middle class or affluent neighborhoods and kids in poor neighborhoods. The US education system is funded, mainly, by local property tax levies. Schools in wealthier areas are generally better funded than schools in poorer areas. The system is rigged to fail children from poor families and they usually do not have the option to choose a private school.

  • kenedwards5

    @robakamegansdad - I think good, motivated kids do rise above systemics problems in education. The problem for me is that there are many kids who are simply not motivated by our education system in the UK. My son was one of these. He's a really great lad, not afraid of hard work (he has always had a job), yet opted out of school through sheer lack of motivation. I let him because I felt we were fighting a losing battle with the education system which did not cater for bright kids. He's happily married now but I do regret him not getting a higher degree of education. Lots of his friends are the same and I really do blame the education system in the UK. The government tries to justify itself by making the exams easier but it is not answering a problem of an education system that stinks! Our system not only fails poor kids but also bright kids too! Pardon me for letting off steam on your blog!! Ken

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

Who recommended?

Who gave the eProps?

2 eProps from: